Idaho Commissioner’s Elk Scandal Ends in Resignation

Idaho Commissioner’s Elk Scandal Ends in Resignation

November 20, 2026 by Angela Montana

In her reporting for Outdoor Life, eastern Idaho journalist and outdoor writer Kris Millgate highlights a situation that has hunters questioning who really has to play by the rules in Idaho. Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger resigned Wednesday after mounting pressure from sportsmen and lawmakers following a plea deal involving two illegally killed bull elk. The twist? Harshbarger was appointed to help oversee the very hunting regulations he admitted violating, pleading guilty to hunting without a tag and shooting across a road, while five additional charges, including illegal elk kills and trespassing, were dismissed as part of the deal. As Millgate reports, the controversy has left many frustrated, especially when commissioners are expected to uphold the standards they help establish.

Idaho Wildlife Federation Executive Director Nick Fasciano summed up the bigger issue, telling Millgate, “Public trust is difficult to earn and easily lost.” And perhaps the most telling part of the story is that the potential consequences could be as little as a $500 fine and a one-year hunting suspension. Millgate also points out that the Idaho Department of Fish and Game is likely to take heat for a situation its staff didn’t control, noting that “the commission and the director were not able to drive a resolution here and they are also not responsible for the sentencing.” At the end of the day, hunters aren’t just watching an elk-poaching case unfold. They’re watching to see whether accountability applies equally to everyone, even those sitting at the table writing the rules.