Now this is a catch you don’t see every day. One angler thought he had dinner on the line—until he reeled in what looked an awful lot like a human hand. Fingernails and all. He says he hopes it’s rubber (and honestly, so do we), but there is just enough hesitation in his voice to keep things creepy. In a world overflowing with fake fishing videos, Halloween props, and pranksters looking for views, odds are it is not real. Still… what if it is? Either way, it has us wondering: what’s the weirdest or downright creepiest thing you’ve ever pulled out of the water?