If you’ve hunted Montana long enough, you may remember the leaner years, depending on where you were. Derek Horner, Outdoor Life’s audience development manager and a central-Pennsylvania deer hunter of about 20 years, says those lean days might be over. Having grown up in Pennsylvania’s opening-day pressure cooker, where a million hunters took to the woods, and he saw more hunters than deer, Horner has watched whitetail numbers soar nationwide over the past decade — a trend he calls “fact, not opinion.” He cites Kip Adams, chief conservation officer for the National Deer Association: “There are between 30 to 35 million whitetails in the U.S. right now,” a population backed by harvest data showing we’ve surpassed three million bucks harvested annually four times in the last century, all within the past five years. Add crossbows now legal nearly everywhere, straight-wall cartridges opening up former shotgun-only states, and Horner’s cellular trail cameras — the same ones that helped pattern his father’s buck through its daylight scrape routine — and his verdict lands hard: “If you can’t shoot a deer today, you just really aren’t trying very hard.” Deer hunting, he argues, has never been easier.
But that ease is exactly what keeps Horner up at night. Hunting, he says, was never supposed to be easy…the thrill of the chase, the failed seasons that taught him more than the successful ones ever did, and the woodsmanship tested were the whole point, and he wonders what the hook will be for kids today if the app does the scouting for them. “I fear we’re very close to crossing the line into an unfair advantage over our quarry, if we haven’t gotten there already,” he admits, and he doesn’t expect state agencies to draw the line for us — he puts that weight on each hunter, this season, sitting in the stand.
So, if you live and/or hunt here in Montana…where do you stand? With our fair-chase culture and whitetails and muleys spread across the state, is easier hunting a win for recruitment and opportunity, or are we trading the soul of the hunt for convenience? Does a cell camera that texts you a buck’s travel schedule still count as scouting? Horner is asking himself the same question.
Montana's outdoor week, in your inbox at 7am Friday.